Buffalo Environmental Law Journal
First Page
53
Document Type
Article
Abstract
About thirty miles northeast of Albany, New York lies the town of Hoosick Falls, a small post-industrial town and the former home to manufacturers Saint-Gobain and Honeywell. In 2014, a local resident reported high levels of perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA), a toxic chemical linked to various cancers and health conditions, in the village’s municipal drinking water to local government officials. Despite its earlier discovery, residents were not instructed to stop consuming the water until late 2015, and the water supply was not declared safe for consumption until March of 2016, roughly a year and a half after officials were first alerted. This delay contributed to harm to residents, creating lasting health effects. Thus, what began as a personal project for one resident became the discovery of a public health crisis in Hoosick Falls that would be riddled with failures of law and leadership.
In examining the story of Hoosick Falls’ water crisis, this case study highlights the challenge of regulations trailing the available science, environmental justice concerns affecting small and rural communities, and the need for leaders to act even when the law may not require it or the facts pertaining to a crisis may be uncertain. These lessons learned may be considered in light of the continued inadequacy of environmental regulations and protections for drinking water, and the challenges faced by leaders as they navigate novel crises. This note analyzes the failures of law and leadership in Hoosick Falls’ water crisis so its story may be considered as a case study with the hope that the next environmental disaster, wherever it may be, is handled in a better manner.
Recommended Citation
Sarah McGovern,
Failure of Law and Leadership in the Hoosick Falls Water Crisis,
33
Buff. Envtl. L.J.
53
(2026).
Available at:
https://digitalcommons.law.buffalo.edu/belj/vol33/iss1/3